|
Compared to... five 8mp's
On this page we will examine the feature / specification differences between the five current eight megapixel prosumer digital cameras as well as some results from our testing / our experiences with the cameras. On the next page you will find our standard studio comparison.
Primary specification / feature differences
<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=2 width=530 align=center border=0><TBODY><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm> </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Canon
Pro1 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Nikon
Coolpix 8700 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Olympus
C-8080 WZ</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Konica Minolta
DiMAGE A2</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Sony
DSC-F828</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Sensor CFA</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>RGBE</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Lens zoom</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>7x</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>8x</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>5x</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>7x</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>7x</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Zoom type</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Motor, ring</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Motor, lever</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Motor, lever</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Mechanical, ring</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Mechanical, ring</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Zoom wide (eq.)</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>28 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>35 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>28 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>28 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>28 mm</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Zoom tele (eq.)</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>200 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>280 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>140 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>200 mm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>200 mm</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Zoom steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>40 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>31 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>18 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Infinite</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Infinite</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Stabilized</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Yes, CCD</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>ND Filter</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Yes</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>No</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Lens aperture</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>F2.4 - F3.5 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>F2.8 - F4.2 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>F2.4 - F3.5 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>F2.8 - F3.5 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>F2.0 - F2.8 </TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Normal focus</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>50 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>50 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>80 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>50 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>50 cm</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Macro focus</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>3 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>3 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>5 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>13 cm</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>2 cm</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Metering modes</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Evaluative
CW avg.
Spot
Spot AF area
</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>256 seg Matrix
CW avg.
Spot
Spot AF area
</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Digital ESP
Spot
Multi-spot
CW avg.</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>300 seg Multi
CW avg.
Spot
Spot AF area
</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Multi-pattern
CW avg.
Spot</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Sensitivity</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>ISO 50 - 400
4 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>ISO 50 - 400
4 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>ISO 50 - 400
9 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>ISO 64 - 800
5 steps</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>ISO 64 - 800
5 steps</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Continuous</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>2.5 fps
5 frames</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>2.5 fps
5 frames</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>1.6 fps
5 frames</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>2.7 fps
3 frames</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>2.5 fps
7 frames</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Movie clips</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>640, 15 fps
320, 15 fps
Limited
</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>640, 30 fps
320, 15 fps
Limited</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>640, 15 fps
320, 15 fps
160, 15 fps
Streaming</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>544, 15/30 fps
320, 15/30 fps
Limited </TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>640, 30 fps
640, 16 fps
160, 8 fps
Streaming </TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Color space</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>sRGB
Adobe RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>sRGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>sRGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>sRGB
Adobe RGB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>sRGB
sYCC</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Image params</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Sharpness +/-1
Contrast +/-1
Saturation +/-1</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Sharpness +/-1
Contrast +/-1
Saturation +/-2</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Sharpness +/-5
Contrast +/-5
Saturation +/-5
Hue +/-5</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Sharpness +/-1
Contrast +/-5
Saturation +/-5</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Sharpness +/-1
Contrast +/-1
Saturation +/-1
Color mode</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>LCD</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>2.0" Tilt/Twist
235,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>1.8" Tilt/Twist
134,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>1.8" Tilt
134,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>1.8" Tilt
113,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>1.8" Tilt
134,000 pixels</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>EVF</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>235,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>235,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>240,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>922,000 pixels</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>235,000 pixels</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Histogram</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Record review
Playback</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Live view
Playback </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Live view
Direct live view
Record review
Playback </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Live view
Record review
Playback</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Live view
Record review
Playback </TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Storage</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Compact Flash</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Compact Flash</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>xD-Picture Card
Compact Flash</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Compact Flash</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>MS Pro
Compact Flash</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Connectivity</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>USB 1.1</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>USB 1.1</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>USB 2.0</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>USB 2.0</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>USB 2.0</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Timelapse</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Yes</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Yes</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>No</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Yes</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>No</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Remote control</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Supplied IR</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Optional wired</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Supplied IR</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Optional wired</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Optional wired</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Dimensions (mm)</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>118 x 72 x 90 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>113 x 105 x 78</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>124 x 85 x 99</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>117 x 85 x 114 </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>134 x 91 x 156</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Weight (g)</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>640</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>512</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>724</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>654</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>906</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
From a specification / features point of view all of the cameras provide a very good range of photographic control and features. If we were to pick out one or two cameras I would probably put the Konica Minolta DiMAGE A2, Nikon Coolpix 8700 and Sony DSC-F828 at the top. I'm also a big believer in the significant advantages of mechanically linked zoom rings and the DiMAGE A2 and DSC-F828 are the only two cameras here which offer that.
Performance differences
<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=2 width=530 align=center border=0><TBODY><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm> </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Canon
Pro1 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Nikon
Coolpix 8700 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Olympus
C-8080 WZ</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Konica Minolta
DiMAGE A2</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Sony
DSC-F828</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Startup</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>AF speed</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Off to taken</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Shot to shot</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Continuous</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>File Write</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88> </TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Battery Life</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88> </TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
One camera appears to shine through from a performance point of view and that's the Sony DSC-F828 which was almost always responsive to use and delivers a more 'real time' photography experience. The Olympus C-8080 Wide Zoom also performed very well, its sub one second startup time is a real eye opener.
Image quality differences
<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=2 width=530 align=center border=0><TBODY><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm> </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Canon
Pro1 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Nikon
Coolpix 8700 </TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Olympus
C-8080 WZ</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Konica Minolta
DiMAGE A2</TD><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm align=middle width=88>Sony
DSC-F828</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Resolution</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>ISO noise</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Above Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Auto WB</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Flash perf.</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>oor</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Night exp.</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Macro</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Very Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Distortion</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Vignetting</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmhigh vAlign=top width=88>Good</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Below Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Above Average</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Fringing</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>Average</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>oor</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tdlabelsimpsm vAlign=top>Add. issues</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>None</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>None</TD><TD class=tdcontentsm vAlign=top width=88>None</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Soft images</TD><TD class=tdcontentsmlow vAlign=top width=88>Green hue shift</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
It's interesting that the cameras from Nikon and Canon both delivered an average performance and the Olympus C-8080 Wide Zoom comes through strong with low noise, good white balance, good image processing and a quality lens which exhibits virtually no problems. The Sony DSC-F828 and Konica Minolta DiMAGE A2 performed the least well, although the DSC-F828 delivered good results in most of the tests its strong purple fringing issue can't be ignored. The DiMAGE A2's 7x zoom lens is showing its age and really can't deliver consistently high resolution to this tiny eight megapixel sensor. |
|